Within hours of being injected with insulin intended for her roommate, 93-year-old Emma Lewis’s blood sugar plummeted, leading to her rushed transport to a nearby medical center. Twelve days later, she died. The licensed practical nurse who administered the fatal injection in May 2022, Felicia Kaye, was not a permanent employee of Peachtree Centre, where Ms. Lewis resided. Instead, Kaye was a gig worker who had secured the shift through the nursing app ShiftKey. Unfamiliar with Ms. Lewis or her roommate, and having received no orientation on the facility’s specific policies and procedures, Kaye described her onboarding as a rudimentary process: "It’s pretty much you get the keys [to the medication cart] and just figure it out yourself." Kaye declined to comment for this story.
This tragic incident is not an isolated event. An in-depth investigation by Proof News and WIRED has revealed a disturbing pattern: the proliferation of gig workers, facilitated by platforms like ShiftKey, is flooding understaffed nursing homes across America, creating a revolving door of temporary caregivers and jeopardizing the well-being of the nation’s elderly and infirm. ShiftKey, a platform boasting a network of over 10,000 healthcare facilities, many of them nursing homes, and more than 200,000 healthcare workers, functions as a digital marketplace connecting facilities with readily available staff. However, evidence from numerous court filings, federal inspection reports, and interviews with former employees, attorneys, and gig nurses themselves paints a stark picture of a system that frequently thrusts workers into critical care environments with minimal to no onboarding, leading to perilous situations.
The implications of this model are profound, raising serious questions about patient safety, accountability, and the very future of elder care in an increasingly digitized world. The rush to fill staffing gaps, often driven by financial pressures on nursing homes, appears to be eclipsing the fundamental need for thorough training and familiarity with individual patient needs.
A Pattern of Errors and Allegations
The dangers associated with ShiftKey’s model are not confined to medication errors. Federal inspection reports detail a series of alarming incidents. In January, a surveyor from the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) documented a ShiftKey worker’s botched attempt to insert a PICC line, a critical venous access device, without prior verification of the worker’s competency. In 2025, another CMS surveyor noted a Texas nursing home’s failure to orient temporary workers on resident feeding protocols before a ShiftKey worker attempted to force-feed a resident with a syringe. Later that same year, a Texas nursing home banned a ShiftKey worker after a resident under their care was found soiled and neglected in urine and feces.
Beyond critical care lapses, allegations of abuse and theft have also surfaced. In the summer of 2026, at Hillsboro Rehab in Illinois, a ShiftKey worker was accused of stealing debit cards from two residents and subsequently using one of them for personal purchases. According to the inspection report, the nursing home promptly notified ShiftKey and blocked the worker within the app to prevent future assignments at their facility. The worker was later arrested, and the affected residents were reimbursed, as confirmed by Tim Blythe, regional vice president of operations for Tutera, Hillsboro Rehab’s parent company. "We sincerely regret this unfortunate incident," Blythe stated in an email, adding that an internal investigation was conducted, and relevant authorities were notified.
Further incidents include an accusation of assault in Texas in 2022, where a ShiftKey worker allegedly slapped a resident. In Tennessee in 2023, another worker was accused of "verbal abuse." More recently, in February 2025, at The Center at Grande in Texas, a third worker faced accusations of stealing hundreds of dollars from four residents. None of the implicated facilities responded to requests for comment regarding these allegations.

ShiftKey’s Business Model: The "Uber for Nursing"?
ShiftKey positions itself as an innovative solution to the persistent staffing challenges in the healthcare sector, drawing parallels to the ride-sharing giant Uber. "We applied technology to the nurse staffing industry," reads an internal company memo obtained by Proof News and WIRED, emphasizing its role in directly connecting healthcare facilities with available caregivers. Mike Vitek, CEO of ShiftKey, stated in a press release, "Our technology is part of the solution to [the] patient care crisis by allowing highly experienced nurses to work on the schedules they choose and by enabling healthcare facilities to quickly fill care gaps and deliver patient care."
While ShiftKey advertises a broad spectrum of open shifts across various healthcare settings, including addiction treatment centers, psychiatric hospitals, and correctional institutions, an analysis of over 100,000 available shifts between March and August 2026 revealed that a staggering 89 percent were in nursing homes. The platform primarily offers shifts for lower-paid nursing roles, such as licensed practical nurses (LPNs) and certified nursing assistants (CNAs), careers that typically do not require a bachelor’s degree and offer average hourly wages between $20 and $30, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Vitek, in his statement, refuted the notion that the gig nursing model is inherently harmful, attributing such issues to "long-standing, systemic issues within the healthcare ecosystem." He asserted that ShiftKey conducts credential verification, background checks, and abuse registry checks, making this information available to facilities. Crucially, Vitek emphasized, "training or orientation required by any facility to operate within its policies is conducted by that individual facility. At ShiftKey, we do not employ nurses—we simply enable their access to flexible shifts."
The platform heavily relies on automation. Its software allows facilities to automatically post and accept shifts. A "reliability score" is assigned to workers based on a "formula-based calculation," which nurses report impacts their ability to secure shifts. Additionally, ShiftKey offers features like shift scoring, last-minute pricing adjustments, and dynamic pricing based on demand and supply, as indicated by company job postings and employee professional profiles. Vitek stated that when concerns are raised, a human reviews them, evaluating claims of "medical malpractice or abuse, neglect, or exploitation of a patient" to determine if deactivation of the worker is appropriate. However, he declined to comment on specific cases due to privacy and ongoing litigation, acknowledging that delayed notification can hinder prompt action.
The Human Cost: A Case Study
The tragic death of Emma Lewis underscores the potential consequences of this system. Felicia Kaye, the nurse involved, testified that she was not prevented from working on the ShiftKey platform after the insulin incident. In legal filings, both ShiftKey and Peachtree Centre have sought to distance themselves from liability. ShiftKey argued that Kaye was never its employee, while Peachtree claimed it could not be held liable for the actions of an independent contractor. Kaye is not named as a defendant in the lawsuit, and ShiftKey has agreed to a $40,000 settlement with the Lewis family.
Peachtree Centre, citing pending litigation, declined to comment. In court, the facility highlighted that Ms. Lewis had multiple pre-existing conditions and that her death certificate listed "senile degeneration of the brain" as the cause. Kaye’s testimony revealed she had driven over 250 miles to work the Peachtree overnight shift. Despite having over two years of experience, she reported receiving no orientation, not even a tour, before being tasked with overseeing a floor of 22 patients as the sole nurse. "This particular shift I had a lot of patients," she testified. "It was very overwhelming."
The complaint filed by the Lewis family against Peachtree and ShiftKey articulated their trust in the facility to "properly train staff" to care for their "vulnerable" mother. James Lewis, Ms. Lewis’s son, expressed his grief in a deposition: "I’ll never get Mom back. I just don’t want it to happen to anybody else."
.jpg)
"Walking Into a Shit Show": The Gig Nurse Experience
Kara Smith, a certified nursing assistant (CNA) in West Virginia, exemplifies the experiences of many gig nurses. Unable to predict her next workplace, Smith logs into the ShiftKey app daily, searching for eight-hour shifts at various long-term care facilities within driving distance of her home. Attracted by the promise of scheduling flexibility and higher pay for challenging shifts, Smith became a ShiftKey contractor in 2022. She soon discovered that nursing homes staffed entirely by ShiftKey workers, even for night shifts, were not uncommon.
Founded in 2016, ShiftKey experienced exponential growth during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nursing homes, grappling with widespread outbreaks that claimed numerous lives, faced severe staffing shortages. Healthcare workers, facing heightened risks, sought better compensation, while facilities desperately tried to fill vacant positions. Backed by private equity, ShiftKey and its competitors, Clipboard Health and IntelyCare, flourished. A U.S. Department of Health and Human Services analysis indicated that from 2019 to 2022, the utilization of contract staff in nursing homes tripled from 4% to 12% of all nursing hours, a rate that, while declining, remains elevated compared to pre-pandemic levels. In 2023, ShiftKey’s then-CEO reported the company’s valuation exceeded $2 billion.
Nursing homes pay ShiftKey a set rate for workers. The platform then "mathematically" calculates a "suggested" rate for each posted shift. Vitek stated that dynamic pricing is employed solely to increase pay for "difficult-to-fill" shifts, not to reduce rates. Workers then bid on these shifts. This bidding system initially appealed to Smith, allowing her to negotiate for higher pay rather than accepting a facility’s initial offer. "If I can even make 25 cents extra, I’m going to try to push for that," Smith, a single mother, remarked, highlighting the financial pressures many face. "Every penny counts."
However, numerous nurses who spoke with Proof News and WIRED reported a significant decline in wages on ShiftKey since the pandemic. Teresa, an LPN who asked for her last name to be withheld, joined ShiftKey in 2019 but stopped using the platform last year due to increasing competition for shifts and decreasing pay rates. "People were fighting over trash shifts for under $20 an hour," she stated. Smith recalled being able to bid $3 to $4 above the facility’s suggested rate when she first joined, but now feels compelled to accept lower pay to secure work. Her payment records shared with Proof News and WIRED show a decline from $32.50 per hour in the summer of 2025 to approximately $26 per hour a year later at one facility, with similar trends observed at another. Many ShiftKey workers have shared similar experiences in online forums. "The starting bids are shamefully low," Smith lamented. "It’s not worth the workload or the drive."
Smith also described a consistent feeling of being "thrown in" at new facilities without orientation, clear instructions, or necessary logins. She often had to exert considerable effort to familiarize herself with residents’ conditions, as critical information, such as fall risks or individuals with catheters or ostomies, was frequently missing. This lack of information left her feeling adrift and overwhelmed. "We’re coming there because they’re short-handed," Smith explained. "So we are automatically going to be walking into a shit show."
This absence of orientation has led to near-misses. Smith recounted arriving at a Virginia nursing home with no advance information, not even a door code, and no knowledge of the patients, causing significant stress. "I know my blood pressure went up because of it," she stated. On another occasion, she delivered a regular drink to a resident, only to later discover the resident was on a thickened liquids diet to prevent choking. "What if they choked and died?" Smith questioned.
Facilities using ShiftKey have the option to require a paid "orientation shift" before regular assignments. However, four ShiftKey workers informed Proof News and WIRED that they have frequently worked nursing home shifts without completing such an orientation.

Regulatory Scrutiny and Systemic Failures
Federal inspection reports from CMS, dating back to 2023, reveal dangerous mistakes made by ShiftKey workers. In Ohio, a ShiftKey nurse’s PICC line error at Stellar Care Center prompted a federal inspection report noting that the nursing home’s administrators had never verified the nurse’s training in IV therapy. An administrator reportedly spoke with ShiftKey, who stated that as all workers were considered independent contractors, the company did not test for specific skills.
In other instances, orientation proved inadequate. At Woodway Rehabilitation and Healthcare Center in Texas, a federal health surveyor observed a ShiftKey worker attempting to force-feed a resident a health shake via an oral syringe. The worker indicated it was her first time at the facility and recalled receiving some app-based orientation but was unsure if feeding protocols were included. In 2024, a CMS surveyor reported that a ShiftKey nurse at the Medical Suites at Oak Creek in Wisconsin stated she was not shown any resident care plans on her first day. The administrator provided an undated orientation checklist and indicated a policy regarding gig nurse orientation was forthcoming. None of the implicated facilities responded to requests for comment.
Researchers warn that the constant movement of unoriented gig nurses between facilities disrupts continuity of care. Jasmine Travers Altizer, an assistant professor at New York University’s Rory Meyers College of Nursing, found in a recent study of nursing home administrators that reliance on temporary workers led to "less consistent care, more hospital transfers, potentially unnecessary treatments and antibiotic use, and increased falls." Administrators also noted reduced staff support for one another. "Gig nursing shouldn’t be a fix for chronic understaffing," Travers Altizer stressed. "It’s critical to have consistent staff who know the residents."
ShiftKey CEO Mike Vitek responded to these concerns by stating, "Continuity of care is an important consideration in nursing home quality, but the issue predates platforms like ours." He further argued that ShiftKey’s model helps retain nurses in the industry, citing a survey where over a third of ShiftKey workers indicated they would leave healthcare without such platforms. "We reject the premise that enabling independent flexible nursing support is harmful to the industry," Vitek concluded.
The Shadow of Private Equity and Deregulation
Katie Wells, a researcher tracking gig nursing, attributes the rise of platforms like ShiftKey to a confluence of factors. Financial struggles within healthcare facilities, coupled with private equity acquisitions, have often resulted in lean staffing models, making facilities more inclined to "plug the hole" with temporary staff rather than invest in permanent employees. Data from CMS indicates that at Peachtree Centre, the average nursing staff hours per resident were below the state average and below minimum requirements set by the Biden administration, which were later challenged and withdrawn by the Trump administration, reportedly saving nursing homes billions over a decade. "We need to have minimum safe staffing levels," stated Hannah Garden-Monheit, formerly of the White House National Economic Council. "The patients need that continuity of care."
Interviews with six ShiftKey nurses and two former corporate employees suggest that many facilities utilizing ShiftKey have a history of poor care quality and staffing issues. One nurse recounted encountering rats and roaches at a nursing home. Constance Hicks, a long-time CNA in Connecticut, described working at numerous ShiftKey-staffed nursing homes in dire conditions, lacking basic supplies and, in some cases, hot water. She reported never receiving any training at these facilities.
In November 2023, while working a double shift at Cobalt Lodge Healthcare, Hicks discovered an elderly patient trapped in a bed rail, suffering from critically high blood pressure. She remained until emergency services arrived. Despite documenting the incident and reporting it to ShiftKey, she received no response. The following day, her ShiftKey account was deactivated. Hicks, who experienced significant psychological trauma from the incident, attempted to sue ShiftKey but her case was moved to private arbitration. Cobalt Lodge Healthcare did not respond to requests for comment, and ShiftKey cited ongoing litigation. Vitek stated that when professionals raise concerns, they are encouraged to use formal reporting channels and can choose not to accept future shifts at those facilities.

Legislative Scrutiny and Worker Misclassification
Some lawmakers are now scrutinizing platforms like ShiftKey, particularly concerning the alleged misclassification of workers as independent contractors. Minnesota State Representative Emma Greenman argues, "It’s not like they’re coming in, bringing their own tools, fixing a pipe, and leaving. They are being managed by somebody." ShiftKey maintains its role as a technology marketplace, connecting independent professionals with facilities. Vitek stated the company works "tirelessly" to ensure legal compliance. Greenman is advocating for legislation to curb worker misclassification in Minnesota, asserting, "What they’re doing is building business models to evade, break, and distort labor law for profit."
The reliance of nursing homes on gig workers is also a point of contention. In the year Emma Lewis died, nearly a third of the total nursing staff hours at Peachtree were provided by temporary workers, according to CMS data. Gary Poliakoff, an attorney for the Lewis family, noted that at times, this rate, including ShiftKey workers, climbed to 50 percent. He contends that this model, with minimal orientation, places both patients and workers at a "great disadvantage."
James Lewis recalled the devastating call informing him of his mother’s hospitalization. He was unaware that Peachtree sometimes utilized temporary workers, stating in his deposition, "I don’t know if it was a traveling nurse or what. But I know it wasn’t a regular person."
Felicia Kaye, in her testimony, attributed the insulin mix-up to understaffing. She described Peachtree as a "shithole" and a facility where she felt unsupported by administration and largely alone. "I remember being not helped at all by administration, not knowing who anyone was," Kaye testified. "And pretty much being by myself." The tragic case of Emma Lewis serves as a stark reminder of the human cost when profit motives and technological convenience potentially overshadow the fundamental human need for safe, consistent, and well-trained care for the most vulnerable members of society.
