Large bitcoin holders are swapping coins they guard themselves for shares of BlackRock’s iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) at a record pace, the firm’s head of digital assets said Monday, as kidnappings and hacks push security to the top of their list. This significant shift underscores a growing trend of institutionalization within the cryptocurrency market, as investors prioritize the perceived safety and regulatory compliance offered by traditional financial products.
Robbie Mitchnick, BlackRock’s head of digital assets, articulated the magnitude of this trend in a recent interview with Barron’s. "The current moment is the highest we’ve seen at any point," Mitchnick stated, emphasizing that demand for these “in-kind” swaps has been consistently upward. He further elaborated that when clients articulate their motivations for this transition, "the single largest one is security and peace of mind." This sentiment reflects a palpable anxiety among significant bitcoin owners regarding the inherent risks associated with self-custody, particularly in light of escalating security threats.
These transactions, known as in-kind conversions, represent a sophisticated mechanism for migrating digital assets into traditional investment vehicles. Instead of liquidating their bitcoin holdings for fiat currency and then purchasing shares of the iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT), holders directly deliver their bitcoin to the fund. This is facilitated through an intermediary, and in return, they receive newly created IBIT shares. This process effectively bypasses the need for immediate cash conversion, potentially offering tax advantages and a more seamless transition for large-scale investors. BlackRock has partnered with established financial institutions, including Galaxy Digital, Talos, and Virtu, to manage these complex transactions, with these firms also playing a role in setting the minimum thresholds for participation.
Barron’s estimated the volume of these in-kind conversions processed by BlackRock to be around $3.6 billion. However, the actual figure is likely higher, as BlackRock does not directly handle every conversion itself. Earlier in August, Mitchnick provided a more expansive figure, telling Bloomberg that IBIT had facilitated over $5 billion in such swaps, a substantial increase from over $3 billion recorded in October 2025. This upward trajectory highlights the accelerating pace at which large bitcoin holders are seeking to integrate their digital assets within the regulated financial system.
In his August interview with Bloomberg, Mitchnick candidly detailed the specific threats driving this migration. "People see things happen in the outside world – whether it’s kidnappings, ransom, custody failures – that motivate them to make this switch for all or some of their holdings," he explained. The growing awareness of these real-world dangers has made the prospect of directly holding and securing large amounts of bitcoin increasingly untenable for many. The recent Binance hack, while significant, was not a revelation to sophisticated bitcoin holders, according to Mitchnick. He noted, "Most large Bitcoin holders were already acutely aware of the risk of holding on an exchange and in a hot wallet." This suggests a pre-existing concern about the security vulnerabilities of digital asset exchanges and less secure storage methods, which the Binance incident may have amplified.
The Regulatory Evolution Enabling In-Kind Conversions
The feasibility of these in-kind conversions is a direct result of a significant regulatory development. On July 29, 2025, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) voted to permit spot bitcoin and ether exchange-traded funds (ETFs) to create and redeem shares in-kind. This decision marked a pivotal departure from the initial cash-only structure mandated when these funds first launched in January 2024. Prior to this ruling, the process for large investors to enter or exit these ETFs was more cumbersome, requiring liquidation of assets into cash.
This regulatory shift has demonstrably widened access and streamlined the process for institutional investors. BlackRock initially set a high minimum for these in-kind conversions, reportedly around $30 million. However, this threshold has since been significantly lowered, now hovering between $1 million and $2 million, according to Barron’s. This reduction in the minimum investment requirement has made the iShares Bitcoin Trust accessible to a broader range of substantial bitcoin holders, further fueling the current surge in in-kind transactions.
Beyond the immediate security concerns, tax implications also play a crucial role in the appeal of in-kind conversions. As Barron’s reported, converting appreciated bitcoin into IBIT shares in-kind is "generally isn’t seen as a sale that would trigger capital-gains taxes." While Bloomberg has cautioned that the ability to defer an immediate tax bill is contingent on an investor’s specific circumstances, the potential for tax efficiency is a significant draw. Mitchnick also highlighted estate planning as a key benefit, describing it as "much, much simpler" to maintain exposure to bitcoin "within the confines of their private bank." This suggests that integrating digital asset exposure into established wealth management frameworks through regulated products like IBIT simplifies complex financial planning and intergenerational wealth transfer.
Once converted, the underlying bitcoin is held by IBIT’s custodian, an affiliate of Coinbase Prime. Mitchnick described this custody arrangement as an "institutional-grade cold-storage model," implying a high level of security and regulatory compliance. As of November 6, the iShares Bitcoin Trust held a substantial 795,921 BTC, valued at approximately $60.4 billion, underscoring the significant scale of institutional capital flowing into the product.
The Nuance of Flow Data: Overstating New Capital Inflows
While the headline figures for in-kind creations paint a picture of robust new capital entering the market, it’s crucial to understand the mechanics of these transactions. An in-kind creation adds IBIT shares to the fund and is duly reported as a flow. However, crucially, no bitcoin is purchased on the open market during this process. The underlying bitcoin already existed and is simply being "re-wrapped" into ETF shares. Therefore, these headline flow figures can overstate the amount of new cash being injected into the bitcoin ecosystem.
Conversely, cash has been moving in the opposite direction from these ETFs. Data from Farside Investors indicates that U.S. spot bitcoin ETFs experienced outflows of approximately $1.28 billion in the week ending November 6. The iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) accounted for a significant portion of this, with outflows totaling about $1.21 billion. This outflow trend, particularly IBIT’s substantial contribution, represents the largest weekly outflow since June, suggesting that while new capital is being converted into IBIT shares via in-kind mechanisms, there are also investors exiting the ETF structure for other reasons, potentially including profit-taking or shifts in market sentiment.
Self-Custody Under Increasing Pressure
The anxieties driving the migration from self-custody to regulated trusts are well-documented and increasingly alarming. French authorities, for instance, have reported a stark increase in cryptocurrency-related criminal activities. The Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP) cited the national organized crime prosecutor in reporting 77 crypto-linked kidnappings, extortion cases, and home invasions in France during 2026 alone. This figure surpasses the total number of such incidents recorded throughout the entirety of 2025, indicating a significant escalation in criminal targeting of crypto holders. The pervasive fear within the crypto community was tragically underscored last year when Reuters reported that the co-founder of Ledger, a prominent hardware wallet manufacturer, was kidnapped along with his wife, resulting in him losing a finger.
The United States has not been immune to these threats. A foiled plot in Connecticut, where perpetrators attempted to force a family to surrender their bitcoin holdings, serves as a stark reminder of the risks. Bitcoin security researcher Jameson Lopp meticulously maintains a public list of physical attacks targeting bitcoin holders, with documented incidents dating back to 2014. Furthermore, security vulnerabilities, such as the Coldcard bug exposed in August, have also placed hardware wallets under increased scrutiny, prompting concerns about the integrity of even seemingly secure self-custody solutions.
This prevailing trend of shifting towards institutional custody represents a significant departure from bitcoin’s foundational ethos of enabling individuals to hold their own money without reliance on intermediaries. Holders who opt for in-kind conversions are essentially trading the direct control and responsibility of safeguarding their private keys for a brokerage claim on an ETF. This entails exchanging the inherent risks of personal security for a reliance on BlackRock, its appointed custodians, and the market makers facilitating these transactions. While this offers a perceived increase in security and regulatory compliance, it also means relinquishing the direct ownership and control that was once the cornerstone of the cryptocurrency movement. The long-term implications of this institutionalization on the decentralization and ethos of bitcoin remain a subject of ongoing debate and observation within the digital asset community.
