The Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office has officially enacted a new set of regulations governing shared appreciation mortgages (SAMs), introducing rigorous disclosure requirements and consumer protection standards for a niche financial product that has come under intense legal and legislative scrutiny. Effective November 6, the rule seeks to clarify the boundaries of liability for nonprofit lenders and ensure that homeowners are fully apprised of the potential costs associated with these complex equity-sharing arrangements. The move follows growing concerns from consumer advocates that certain loan structures, while marketed as foreclosure prevention tools, may inadvertently strip equity from vulnerable homeowners and create insurmountable debt obligations.
The regulation is a direct response to a provision within the state’s expansive economic development bill, which was signed into law in November 2024. That statute initially provided a broad waiver of liability under Massachusetts consumer protection laws for specific nonprofit SAM providers, most notably BlueHub Capital. However, the Attorney General’s new rule aims to narrow that "loophole" by establishing clear conditions under which lenders can claim such protections, while simultaneously mandating transparency regarding the maximum repayment amounts a borrower might face upon the sale or refinancing of their home.
Understanding the Shared Appreciation Mortgage Model
A shared appreciation mortgage is a specialized home equity product where a lender provides a borrower with a loan—often to assist with a down payment or to prevent foreclosure—in exchange for a portion of the home’s future value increase. Under the model frequently utilized by organizations like BlueHub Capital, a borrower typically receives a fixed-rate first mortgage combined with a second lien. This second lien does not carry a traditional monthly payment; instead, it is tied to the future appreciation of the property.
When the homeowner eventually sells the property, transfers the title, or attempts to refinance the primary mortgage, the "silent" second lien becomes due. The lender then claims a predetermined percentage of the increase in the home’s market value from the time the loan was originated. While this can provide immediate liquidity or debt relief, the long-term costs are often volatile. Because property values in Massachusetts have seen significant growth over the last decade, the share of appreciation owed to the lender can far exceed the original principal, leading to massive balloon payments that catch homeowners off guard.
According to data from the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller Home Price Index, Massachusetts has experienced some of the most consistent property value increases in the United States. For a homeowner who entered a SAM a decade ago, the "appreciation share" could easily amount to six figures, potentially erasing the equity they worked years to build. Advocates argue that because the payoff amount is variable and not set in a fixed dollar amount at the time of signing, these loans function more like high-interest subprime products than charitable assistance.
The Legislative Catalyst and Regulatory Response
The urgency behind the Attorney General’s rulemaking stems from the 2024 economic development bill. While intended to foster growth in sectors like life sciences and AI, the bill included language that shielded certain nonprofit SAM lenders from claims brought under Chapter 93A, the Commonwealth’s primary consumer protection law. This legislative move was met with immediate pushback from the National Consumer Law Center (NCLC) and other advocacy groups, who warned that the waiver would leave distressed homeowners with no legal recourse against predatory terms.
The Attorney General’s final rule, codified as 940 CMR 39, does not ban the use of SAMs but creates a framework for their ethical implementation. Key provisions of the rule include:
- Maximum Repayment Disclosure: Lenders must provide a prominent, clear notice to borrowers detailing the maximum possible amount they could be required to repay. This is intended to eliminate the "sticker shock" that occurs when a home’s value rises faster than anticipated.
- Limited Liability Insulation: The rule specifies that lenders are only shielded from state consumer protection claims if they adhere strictly to the new disclosure and notice standards.
- Prohibited Practices: The regulation outlines specific conduct that remains subject to enforcement, ensuring that even nonprofit entities cannot engage in deceptive marketing or unfair servicing practices.
Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell’s office has emphasized that while nonprofits play a role in stabilizing the housing market, they are not exempt from the obligation to treat borrowers fairly. The rule aims to balance the need for innovative financing with the fundamental right of homeowners to understand the financial instruments they are signing.
Legal Precedent: Humes v. BlueHub Capital Inc.
The risks associated with shared appreciation models are not merely theoretical. They have been at the center of a high-profile class-action lawsuit, Humes v. BlueHub Capital Inc., which has significantly influenced the regulatory landscape in Massachusetts. In this case, plaintiffs alleged that BlueHub’s SAM products contained hidden costs that functioned as subprime interest rates, effectively stripping equity from low-income homeowners and minority communities who were targeted for foreclosure intervention.
The court in the Humes case found that BlueHub was liable for violating multiple state lending laws. More recently, the court certified the class, allowing the litigation to move forward on behalf of a broader group of affected homeowners. The NCLC has pointed to this case as evidence that the "lifeline" offered by SAMs can easily become a financial trap. Andrea Bopp Stark, a senior attorney at the NCLC, noted that while the AG’s new rule is a vital step in protecting residents from the BlueHub model, it highlights a broader trend of "equity theft" that requires even more aggressive oversight.
The Emerging Threat of Home Equity Investments (HEIs)
While the new Massachusetts rule addresses SAMs, a similar but distinct product—Home Equity Investments (HEIs)—remains largely unregulated in the state. HEIs provide homeowners with upfront cash in exchange for a share of the home’s future value, but unlike SAMs, they are often marketed as "investments" rather than "loans." This distinction is critical because it allows HEI providers to argue that they are not subject to traditional usury caps, truth-in-lending disclosures, or mortgage licensing requirements.
The NCLC and other consumer watchdogs characterize HEIs as high-risk products. Because the repayment is a lump sum triggered by a sale or the end of a fixed term (often 10 to 30 years), homeowners who do not have the cash on hand to "buy out" the investor may be forced to sell their homes.
Attorney General Campbell has already taken aim at this sector, filing a lawsuit against the HEI provider Hometap. The state alleges that Hometap’s practices violate consumer protection laws by failing to disclose the true cost of the capital provided. However, the current rulemaking for SAMs does not explicitly cover HEIs, leading to calls for the legislature to close what advocates describe as a "growing gap" in the state’s financial safety net.
National Regulatory Trends and Industry Perspectives
Massachusetts is not alone in its struggle to regulate shared-equity products. Across the United States, courts and regulators are grappling with how to categorize these instruments.
- Washington State: The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently overturned a lower court ruling, determining that an HEI product offered by Unison was, in fact, a "reverse mortgage" under state law. This ruling has major implications for how these products must be licensed and disclosed.
- Minnesota: In August 2024, the Minnesota Attorney General’s Office reached a settlement with the provider Unlock. The state alleged that Unlock’s home equity agreements were actually mortgage loans that violated state interest rate caps and disclosure rules.
- Illinois: Earlier this year, Illinois passed a comprehensive legal framework for shared equity products. This legislation is being viewed by some industry experts as a potential national model, as it provides a clear path for compliance while maintaining consumer safeguards.
Representatives from the industry have expressed a willingness to accept regulation, provided it accounts for the unique nature of their products. During the Mortgage Bankers Association’s Annual Convention, executives from Point, another major player in the HEI space, acknowledged that universal regulations are likely inevitable. Dan McPheeters, Point’s head of business development, noted that while it is difficult to apply traditional "self-amortizing" loan rules to products without monthly payments, a standardized regulatory framework would provide much-needed market certainty.
Analysis of Implications for Massachusetts Homeowners
The implementation of 940 CMR 39 marks a pivotal moment for the Massachusetts housing market. By demanding transparency, the Attorney General’s office is signaling that "innovation" in the mortgage sector cannot come at the expense of consumer clarity.
For nonprofit lenders, the rule provides a roadmap for avoiding litigation, though it significantly raises the bar for operational compliance. For homeowners, particularly those in distressed financial situations, the rule provides a "right to know." They will now have access to a clear "worst-case scenario" figure before committing their home’s future value to a third party.
However, the exclusion of HEIs from this specific rulemaking suggests that the battle over home equity is far from over. As property values continue to rise, the incentive for private equity firms and nonprofits to "buy into" residential real estate will only grow. The NCLC continues to urge the Commonwealth to adopt even broader protections, including:
- Applying interest rate caps to all equity-sharing products.
- Requiring mandatory independent counseling for any homeowner considering a SAM or HEI.
- Establishing a "right to cure" that would allow homeowners to exit these agreements more easily if their financial situation improves.
As the November 6 effective date passes, the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office will likely monitor the market closely to ensure that the spirit of the rule is upheld. The shift toward more rigorous oversight reflects a broader national trend: the recognition that a home is not just a financial asset for an investor, but a primary source of stability and generational wealth for the family living inside it.
