MSCI, a leading global provider of equity, fixed income, and hedge fund index data, announced on Wednesday its decision to remove MicroStrategy (MSTR) from the MSCI USA Index, effective at the close of trading on November 30th. This significant move, part of MSCI’s November 2023 Index Review, stems from a newly implemented screening methodology that classifies MicroStrategy as a non-operating issuer. The exclusion will also impact its inclusion in the broader MSCI World and MSCI ACWI (All Country World Index) indexes, affecting a wide array of global investment portfolios.

The decision follows a rigorous review process by MSCI, which aims to maintain the integrity and representativeness of its indices. The index provider’s new "non-operating issuer" screen is designed to ensure that companies included in its investable market indices have a substantial portion of their assets dedicated to core business operations. Companies that fail to meet these operational criteria are subject to removal.

MicroStrategy, renowned for its substantial corporate Bitcoin holdings, has become a prominent figure in the digital asset space. As of November 8th, the company held a staggering 850,364 Bitcoins, acquired at an average price of $75,456 per coin, representing an aggregate investment of approximately $64.16 billion. This significant allocation to Bitcoin, while a strategic move for the company, has now placed it in a category that MSCI’s updated screening process deems non-operational for index inclusion purposes.

The MSCI November 2023 Index Review, released shortly after 5 p.m. ET on Wednesday, detailed a series of additions and deletions across its various global indices. Alongside MicroStrategy, several other companies were slated for removal. Japan’s Metaplanet and the United Kingdom’s Yellow Cake, both significant uranium holders, were removed from their respective MSCI Japan Small Cap Index and MSCI United Kingdom Small Cap Index. Iceland’s Skel Fjardfestingafélag was removed from the MSCI Iceland Frontier Markets Small Cap Index, and the micro-cap firm Upexi was deleted from the MSCI USA Micro Cap Index. All five companies had previously appeared on MSCI’s "potential-impact list" for non-operating screening, which was compiled based on September 30th financial data and October 9th market valuations.

MicroStrategy stood out as the sole large-cap entity among these deletions. On the October watchlist, it accounted for over 90% of the combined float-adjusted market value of the five companies. This highlights the significant weight MicroStrategy carried within the context of these index adjustments.

The Mechanics of MSCI’s Non-Operating Issuer Screen

The new screening methodology employed by MSCI does not directly mention Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies. Instead, it focuses on the operational nature of a company’s assets. The primary criterion is whether a company’s operating assets constitute at least 50% of its total assets. Issuers failing this initial threshold are then subjected to a secondary review involving five specific financial ratios. If a company is flagged on four or more of these ratios, it becomes ineligible for inclusion in the MSCI Global Investable Market Indexes.

MSCI’s index methodology incorporates buffers to limit excessive turnover. For companies already outside the index, an ineligibility screen failure in either of the two most recent annual filing periods prevents their addition. However, for existing constituents like MicroStrategy, removal is triggered only if they fail the ineligibility screen in both of their two most recent annual filings. MSCI also retains the discretion to consider the most recent interim filing in its assessment.

This updated approach represents a significant shift from MSCI’s previous considerations regarding companies with substantial digital asset holdings. In late 2025, MSCI had initially proposed excluding companies where digital assets comprised 50% or more of their total assets. However, this plan was revised and ultimately dropped in January, leading to a broader consultation in August. The new, more comprehensive "non-operating issuer" methodology was adopted on October 15th, with minor modifications. This also signaled the end of interim measures previously placed on these companies, which had included a freeze on share-count increases and a deferral of additions. MSCI confirmed on Wednesday that this non-operating treatment would also be applied to the MSCI US Index Series.

Implications of the Deletion for MicroStrategy and its Investors

The exclusion of MicroStrategy from the MSCI USA Index, MSCI World, and MSCI ACWI has direct implications for investment funds that track these benchmarks. Such funds are mandated to mirror the holdings of the indices they follow, necessitating the sale of MicroStrategy shares by the November 30th deadline.

While MSCI has not provided an official estimate of the potential outflows, analysts at JPMorgan had previously estimated in November of the prior year that an exclusion from MSCI indices could lead to approximately $2.8 billion in outflows from MicroStrategy. This earlier estimate was based on MSCI’s initial digital asset proposal, not the current non-operating screen, and did not account for potential follow-on actions by other index providers.

It is crucial to note that this removal from MSCI indices does not constitute a delisting of MicroStrategy’s stock from any exchange. Furthermore, the MSCI rules do not compel MicroStrategy to sell its Bitcoin holdings. The primary pressure will be exerted on the company’s stock price, which in turn could affect its ability to leverage its stock through premium offerings to fund new Bitcoin acquisitions.

MicroStrategy has publicly addressed the potential impact of such an index exclusion. In an August letter responding to MSCI’s consultation, the company stated that a deletion "would have no meaningful impact on Strategy’s business." MicroStrategy has also highlighted that funds tracking MSCI’s global investable indices hold approximately 3.1% of its basic shares outstanding. The company further clarifies that under U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), it reports its Bitcoin treasury as an operating segment.

The performance of MicroStrategy shares in after-hours trading on Wednesday reflected some market reaction. The stock closed at $122.35, up 1.06%, before slipping 1.51% to $120.50 in after-hours trading as of 5:34 p.m. ET.

Broader Context and Other Notable Deletions

The decision to reclassify MicroStrategy as a non-operating issuer underscores the evolving landscape of index construction and the challenges faced by companies with unconventional asset allocations. While the screen is designed to be objective, its application to companies like MicroStrategy, which have strategically embraced Bitcoin as a primary treasury asset, generates significant discussion.

The November review also saw the deletion of other companies, albeit smaller in market capitalization compared to MicroStrategy. Metaplanet, a Tokyo-listed firm that has also accumulated Bitcoin, was removed from the MSCI Japan Small Cap Index. This move came after Metaplanet sold a portion of its Bitcoin holdings in the previous quarter to demonstrate its ability to access liquidity from its reserves. In the week leading up to November 8th, MicroStrategy itself purchased an additional 1,036 Bitcoins for $81.9 million, bringing its total holdings to a level that brought its average acquisition cost below its current holdings.

Other companies that were on MSCI’s potential watchlist, including SharpLink, TON Strategy, and Solana Company, were not among the announced deletions in this review cycle. This suggests that while they were under scrutiny, they either met the revised criteria or were not flagged with the same severity as MicroStrategy and the other deleted entities.

The inclusion of companies with significant digital asset holdings in broad market indices has been a topic of ongoing debate within the financial industry. While some argue that such assets represent a legitimate form of corporate treasury management, others express concerns about the volatility and speculative nature of cryptocurrencies, which can diverge from the operational fundamentals typically assessed for index inclusion. MSCI’s latest move signals a clear stance on this matter, prioritizing operational asset allocation as a core requirement for inclusion in its widely followed indices. The long-term impact of this classification on MicroStrategy’s business model and its ability to access capital markets remains to be seen, but the immediate effect will be a forced divestment by index-tracking funds.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *