As the United States grapples with a historic surge in electricity demand driven by the proliferation of data centers, the reshoring of heavy manufacturing, and the electrification of transportation, the nation’s aging power grid has reached a critical bottleneck. While thousands of gigawatts of new energy projects sit in administrative limbo, two landmark studies funded by The Pew Charitable Trusts suggest that a specialized regulatory mechanism known as Surplus Interconnection Service (SIS) could provide an immediate and cost-effective solution. By utilizing the existing, often dormant capacity of current power plants, Ohio and Pennsylvania could collectively unlock up to 37.5 gigawatts (GW) of new energy capacity, potentially saving ratepayers billions of dollars while drastically accelerating the transition to a modern energy economy.
The Growing Crisis of the Interconnection Queue
The American electrical grid is currently facing a dual challenge: skyrocketing demand and a paralyzed application process for new generation. For the past five years, electricity consumption has trended upward with no signs of abatement. To meet this need, developers have proposed a massive influx of wind, solar, and battery storage projects. However, the process of connecting these resources to the grid—known as the interconnection queue—has become a significant barrier to progress.
Across the United States, more than 2,060 GW of generation and storage capacity are currently waiting for approval to come online. In the PJM Interconnection region, which manages the grid for 13 states including Ohio and Pennsylvania, the backlog is particularly acute. For developers in these states, the timeline from initial application to operational status now typically exceeds five years. These delays are not merely administrative; they carry heavy economic consequences. In recent PJM capacity auctions, generation costs have been projected to surge from $29 to $333 per megawatt-day, a price hike that will eventually be reflected in the monthly bills of residential and industrial consumers alike.
Understanding Surplus Interconnection Service
At the heart of the proposed solution is Surplus Interconnection Service (SIS), a mechanism that allows new energy resources to "piggyback" on the existing grid connections of established power plants. Most traditional power plants, particularly natural gas "peaker" plants or older coal units, rarely operate at 100% capacity throughout the entire year. Many remain idle during periods of low demand or serve only as backup during extreme weather events.
SIS enables a new developer—or the owner of the existing plant—to install additional generation, such as a solar array or a utility-scale battery, at the same site. This new resource utilizes the "surplus" capacity of the existing interconnection agreement. For example, a solar farm could be built on the vacant land surrounding a natural gas plant. During the day, the solar farm sends power to the grid; at night or during peak demand, the gas plant provides the necessary load. Because the total output never exceeds the original permitted capacity of the site, the project can often bypass the years-long, complex reliability studies required for entirely new grid connections.
Ohio’s Path to $1.8 Billion in Ratepayer Savings
Ohio is currently at the center of a manufacturing and technology renaissance. With the development of the "Silicon Heartland" and the massive expansion of data center clusters around Columbus, the state’s energy needs are projected to grow significantly through 2035. A study conducted by Roselle LLP and funded by Pew indicates that Ohio’s existing generation fleet is uniquely positioned to meet this demand through SIS.
The research found that roughly 35% of Ohio’s energy facilities operate for less than one-third of the year. These underutilized sites alone represent a latent opportunity to host more than 8.3 GW of new generation or storage. When the analysis was expanded to include the state’s entire generation fleet, researchers concluded that SIS could unlock up to 21 GW of new resources—an amount that roughly aligns with Ohio’s total projected demand growth over the next decade.
The economic implications for Ohio residents are substantial. The study estimates that utilizing SIS could save ratepayers approximately $1.8 billion in avoided interconnection costs. On an individual level, this translates to a savings of roughly $367 per household. Furthermore, because SIS projects utilize existing infrastructure, the timeline to bring new energy online could be slashed from five years to as little as 12 to 18 months.
Pennsylvania’s Opportunity to Revitalize Energy Infrastructure
Pennsylvania, historically a powerhouse of American energy production, faces a different set of challenges. As one of the largest energy exporters in the PJM region, the state maintains a massive fleet of thermal power plants. However, many of these facilities are aging and operating with decreasing frequency as the market shifts toward more competitive resources.
According to research conducted by SilverGreen Energy Consulting, more than 30% of Pennsylvania’s thermal generation capacity remains idle for at least nine months of the year. These plants are often situated on large tracts of industrial land that are ideally suited for co-locating solar panels or large-scale battery systems. The study found that by leveraging these sites, Pennsylvania could realize 6.5 GW of new energy through SIS almost immediately.
In total, the SilverGreen analysis suggests that SIS could unlock up to 16.5 GW of new resources across the Commonwealth. To put this in perspective, Pennsylvania is currently on track to add only 1 GW of new generation in 2026 through the traditional, slow-moving interconnection process. By embracing SIS, the state could not only bolster grid reliability but also insulate consumers from rising costs, with projected savings of more than $1.4 billion in avoided infrastructure upgrades.
A Chronology of Regulatory Evolution
The concept of SIS is not entirely new, but its necessity has been magnified by recent regulatory shifts and market pressures.
- 2018: The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) issued Order 845, which required transmission providers to allow for surplus interconnection service. This established the legal framework, but implementation at the state and regional levels remained inconsistent.
- 2021-2023: A massive influx of renewable energy applications overwhelmed regional transmission organizations (RTOs) like PJM, leading to a "pause" in new applications to process the backlog.
- 2024: States like Indiana and Virginia began passing legislation and issuing regulatory directives requiring utilities to evaluate SIS potential in their integrated resource plans (IRPs).
- 2025: The release of the Pew-funded studies for Ohio and Pennsylvania marks a pivotal moment in quantifying the specific regional benefits of SIS, providing a data-driven roadmap for policymakers in the Rust Belt.
Stakeholder Reactions and Market Implications
The findings of these studies have sparked a dialogue among energy developers, utility companies, and consumer advocates. Environmental groups and renewable energy developers have largely praised the findings, noting that SIS provides a "fast track" for decarbonization that avoids the "not-in-my-backyard" (NIMBY) issues often associated with greenfield projects, since the work takes place on existing industrial sites.
However, some utility providers have expressed caution, citing the need for rigorous technical assessments to ensure that "piggybacking" resources do not compromise the physical integrity of existing substations or transmission lines. Grid operators like PJM are also under pressure to modernize their software and modeling tools to handle the more dynamic power flows created by co-located hybrid resources.
Industry analysts suggest that the adoption of SIS could lead to a new era of "energy hubs," where traditional fossil fuel sites evolve into multi-technology complexes. This transition would allow legacy energy communities to retain their economic relevance while participating in the transition to cleaner energy.
Policy Recommendations and the Road Ahead
The Pew Charitable Trusts and the researchers involved in the studies argue that the technical potential for SIS is clear, but the regulatory path remains cluttered. To realize the billions in savings and gigawatts of power identified in the reports, several policy steps are recommended:
- Mandatory Evaluation: State legislatures could require utilities to include SIS assessments in their long-term planning. By identifying where surplus capacity exists today, states can direct developers toward the most efficient connection points.
- Streamlined Permitting: Since SIS projects are located at already-permitted industrial sites, regulators could create "fast-track" local permitting processes that recognize the reduced environmental impact of using disturbed land.
- Incentivizing Hybrid Projects: Tax credits or state-level incentives could be tailored to reward developers who choose to co-locate storage with existing generation, specifically targeting the stabilization of the grid during peak hours.
The overarching conclusion of the research is that the U.S. grid is currently underperforming relative to its physical capacity. Ohio and Pennsylvania possess the infrastructure necessary to power the next generation of industrial growth; the challenge lies in the administrative and regulatory willpower to unlock it. If the recommendations of these studies are adopted, the region could transform from a cautionary tale of grid congestion into a national model for energy efficiency and economic resilience. By making smarter use of what is already built, the grid can finally begin to catch up with the relentless demand of the 21st century.
